My Name Is Earl: Series Review and Why There Is No Season 5
I just finished watching My Name Is Earl. All 4 seasons of the Hickey brothers’ lives flew by in a flash, along with the life of their small town and everyone in it.

In short: it is a comedy about a small-time thief who comes to believe in karma and sets out to fix every bad thing he has ever done. There are 4 seasons and 96 episodes, and there will be no season 5: the show was cancelled.
What the show is about
Earl Hickey is a small-time crook from the fictional Camden County. He wins $100,000 on a lottery scratcher, gets hit by a car while celebrating and loses the ticket. In the hospital he hears about karma on TV and realizes that every bad thing you do comes back to you.
So he makes a list of everyone he has wronged and starts fixing it one item at a time. Right after his first good deed, the lost ticket turns up on its own, so karma works. Earl spends the money on more good deeds.
The characters
- Earl Hickey (Jason Lee) – a former thief with his list;
- Randy (Ethan Suplee) – Earl’s younger brother, simple-minded and lazy, but always there for him;
- Joy (Jaime Pressly) – Earl’s ex-wife from the trailer park and the source of the sharpest jokes. Pressly won an Emmy for the role in 2007;
- Darnell (Eddie Steeples) – a worker at the local diner and Joy’s new husband;
- Catalina (Nadine Velazquez) – the maid at the motel where the brothers live.

Why there will be no season 5
NBC cancelled the show in May 2009 because the ratings kept falling. Season 1 averaged 11.4 million viewers in the US, season 4 only 6.2 million. The studio tried to sell the show to other networks, including Fox and TBS, but no deal was made: TBS would have needed the budget cut by a million dollars per episode.
The worst part is that season 4 (27 episodes) ended with a “To Be Continued” caption right at the most interesting moment. Earl learns that Dodge is his biological son and that Darnell is not the father of Earl Jr., Joy’s second son. We will never find out who the father is. It is already 2011, and there is no hope left.
Maybe they should have made longer episodes: 20 minutes is just too short.
Is it worth watching?
Yes, absolutely. The episodes are short and easy to watch, the jokes are sharp, and behind the laughs there is a simple idea about karma. The pilot alone won two Emmys, for writing and for directing. If you like it, Earl’s creator Greg Garcia has a new show, Raising Hope, running since fall 2010, with a similar sense of humor.
Doing bad things and wondering why you have no luck? There is an answer: karma.
Do good, and good will come back to you!